Last update: 2016-10-16 19:04:10
 # of Visitors: 2653395
       
 
 Go Back 
 
 Top of List 
KP says: Amanda Stardust vs. Ziggy Ziggy Sputnik        
Updated: 2016-02-06 04:55:47    Type:  music comment     English  View Comment Details   
Amanda Stardust vs. Ziggy Ziggy Sputnik (music comment)
There are 2 ways of approaching a David Bowie tribute.

Sigue Sigue Sputnik did their own version of "Rebel Rebel" [1990], and they played it "live", and that was that. Then Mr. David Bowie made his own b-side version of the SSS song "Love Missile F1-11" in 2003.

Martin Degville, as the sole survivor of the Sputniks - created a very nice Bowie EP "Sputnik vs. Bowie (Part I)" [2009] with the songs: Drive In Saturday, Gene Genie, Life On Mars, Rebel Rebel, Space Oddity, Suffragette City, Ziggy Ziggy SSStardust.

The production could certainly have been better. Had it been, they would have been as good as the originals. Bowie with pure Sputnik sound. We are The Elite.

VERSUS

Amanda Palmer chose the boring way with "Strung Out In Heaven" [2016]. The songs were: Blackstar, Space Oddity, Ashes To Ashes, Heroes, Helden, Life On Mars.

Amandas versions are either so boring or so fucked, that you gotta ask yourself, shouldn't this woman be at home breastfeeding her kid, instead of making really bad cover versions of David Bowie songs? Yes, she probably should. Seriously, it is almost as depressing to listen to as it is to listen to the last Bowie album.

If you want a really cool Bowie inspired song "Major Tom", then listen to this: Peter Schilling caught it perfectly

Mkay. To sum it up. Baby-mama Amanda fucked it up real bad, and Sputnik2 aka Ser Degville made a brilliant EP that mixed everything cool about Bowie with everything Sputnik. And Peter Schilling was pretty cool.

THE WINNER: Sigue Sigue Sputnik
 
Post a REPLY to this Comment            
Cd reviews:
The Dresden Dolls - No, Virginia...  ♦  Martin Degville - G.O.D (guns oil drugs)  ♦  Amanda Palmer - Who Killed Amanda Palmer?  ♦  Martin Degville - Sputnik 2....The Future  ♦  Martin Degville - Space Age Junkie  ♦  Martin Degville - The Prophet Of Freak  ♦  Martin Degville - Sputnik vs. Bowie (part I)  ♦  Sigue Sigue Sputnik Electronik - Futuatronik (EP)  ♦  David Bowie - A Reality Tour (live 2003)  ♦  Sigue Sigue Sputnik Electronic - Flaunt It (promo)  ♦  Amanda Palmer - Goes Down Under  ♦  Sigue Sigue Sputnik Electronic - Flaunt It (factory-pressed and mastered)  ♦  Evelyn Evelyn - Evelyn Evelyn  ♦  Amanda Palmer & The Grand Theft Orchestra - Theatre Is Evil  ♦  Sigue Sigue Sputnik Electronic - Electronic DNA  ♦  David Bowie - The Next Day (deluxe edition)  ♦  The Few Moments  ♦  Iggy Pop & The Stooges: Ready to Die  ♦  Bitter Ruin - Waves  ♦  David Bowie - Nothing Has Changed (3CD)  ♦  David Bowie : Blackstar  ♦  Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds : "Skeleton Tree"  ♦  Amanda Palmer and Edward Ka-Spel : "I Can Spin A Rainbow"
 
Concert reviews:
Nitzer Ebb - Rust - Copenhagen - 2006-10-29  ♦  Sci-fi Superstars- Live @ The Purple Turtle - London, Camden - 20090529  ♦  Nine Inch Nails - Live @ Zenith, Paris, 2009-07-07  ♦  Sigue Sigue Sputnik electronic - Live @ The Underworld, 2009-12-06  ♦  Agnes Obel - DRs Koncerthus, Copenhagen - Denmark - Live - 2011-02-25  ♦  Amanda Palmer - Concorde 2, Brighton - England - Live - 2011-09-01  ♦  Amanda Palmer - Heaven, London - England - Live - 2011-09-02  ♦  Amanda Palmer - Art + Ninja, Village Underground, London 2012-06-18+19  ♦  Amanda Palmer - Rock gig, Village Underground, London 2012-06-20  ♦  Amanda Palmer - C-Club - Berlin, Germany - Live - 2012-10-28  ♦  Amanda Palmer - The Roundhouse - London, Live - 2013-07-12   ♦  Amanda Palmer - Concorde2 - Brighton, England, Live - 2013-07-13  ♦  Amanda Palmer - Pumpehuset - Copenhagen, Live - 2013-10-31   ♦  Depeche Mode @ Parken - Copenhagen, Live, 2017-05-31
 
Music comments:
30 albums I would take with me to a galaxy far far way  ♦  25 albums I would take with me to a galaxy far far way  ♦  "The 12 Lost Records of 2014" - or albums I didn't get around to review...  ♦  Rock 'N' Roll Is Dead! (And It Lived In Minneapolis) - R.I.P. Prince  ♦  The year of shit named 2016 - KP's "Best of vs. Worst of"
 
Music photos:
Amanda Palmer, Concorde2, Brighton, 2013-07-13  ♦  Amanda Palmer, Pumpehuset, Copenhagen, 2013-10-31  ♦  Amanda Palmer, The Roundhouse, London, 2013-07-12  ♦  Amanda Palmer, C-Club, Berlin, 2012-10-28  ♦  London Kick-starter 2012 - 2012-06-18,19,20